Starhopper flew and it looked ridiculous

SpaceX flew Starhopper today.

If you haven’t seen the video, go watch it. I’ll wait. Check NASASpaceflight or SpaceX’s YouTube.

A stainless steel cylinder, roughly the size and shape of a grain silo, lifted off a concrete pad in Boca Chica, Texas, rose about 150 meters into the air, drifted sideways, and landed on a second pad. The whole flight took about a minute. A single Raptor engine did all the work.

And it looked completely ridiculous.

I don’t mean that as criticism. I mean it literally looked like someone had attached a rocket engine to a water tower and hit the ignite button. Because that’s basically what happened. Starhopper is a test article. A stubby, squat, unfinished prototype. It has no fairing, no nose cone, no thermal protection. It looks nothing like the sleek renderings SpaceX shows at their presentations. It looks like it was built in a barn.

(It was basically built in a barn.)

Why I love this

There’s a thing that happens in engineering where the prototype bears no resemblance to the final product. The Wright Flyer looked nothing like a 747. ENIAC looked nothing like an iPhone. The first car looked nothing like a Tesla.

Prototypes are ugly because they’re honest. They’re not trying to impress you. They’re trying to answer a question. Starhopper’s question was simple: can a Raptor engine, burning methane and oxygen, lift a large steel object off the ground and set it down somewhere else?

Yes. Yes it can.

That question sounds modest, but the answer feeds into everything SpaceX is planning for Starship. The full-scale vehicle that might, if the wildly ambitious timeline holds, carry humans to Mars. The one I wrote about last year that looks like a retro sci-fi prop.

A 150-meter hop by a flying water tower is the first step on a road to another planet. That’s absurd and beautiful.

The pattern

I keep noticing this pattern where the future arrives looking stupid. The first iPhone had no copy-paste. The first Tesla had a range of 200 miles and cost more than a house. The first personal computers were less powerful than a modern calculator.

Starhopper is in that tradition. It’s the laughable first step. The thing that, ten years from now, will show up in “look how far we’ve come” montages.

Or it won’t. Maybe Starship never works. Maybe SpaceX hits a wall they can’t engineer around. I’m not a prophet. I’m just a person who watched a grain silo fly today and felt something I can’t quite name.

Hope, maybe. The silly, irrational kind. The kind that watches a water tower hover in the Texas sky and thinks: Mars.

Related thinking: